Part 1:
I used the Lesson Plan Generator in Magic School AI to create a lesson for my first grade special education reading group - to teach VC and basic CVC words. Because of my students' academic delays, my lesson plans do not always align with their current grade level, and instead align with their current instructional level.
For this lesson I asked the Magic School AI generator to align with the Kindergarten Oklahoma Academic Standards for English Language Arts - Standard 2: Reading and Writing Foundations Objective K.2.PWS.4: "Students will blend letter sounds to decode simple Vowel/Consonant (VC) and Consonant/Vowel/Consonant (CVC) words (e.g., VC words = at, in, up; CVC words = pat, hen, lot)." I also connected the lesson to ISTE Student Standard 1.1.c Empowered Learner. I felt this fit best because in a special education setting - immediate, non-judgmental feedback is critical for mastering skills, like phonemic blending. It shifts the student from a passive receiver of instruction to an active agent who uses digital tools to self-correct and build confidence at their own pace.
In my opinion, the Magic School AI lesson would be considered a mid-quality level lesson for my classroom and it's needs. The lesson does align with the standards I provided, and mentions throughout how it connects to both and even offers differentiation and assessment ideas. So some may consider that "sufficiently rigorous" however, my classroom is highly specialized and in need of a keen eye on each student's individual needs and learning strengths/weaknesses. For example, the lesson mentions a few ideas for words to use (at, in, up, cat, sit, sun) but does not take into consideration that having a mix of vowel types when I asked for a very beginner level lesson plan - would actually be pretty tricky for my students. Early on we focus on one specific vowel only and offer a mix of real and nonsense words (at, an, as, ad, av, ap, cat, rat). Then as far as the technology piece, it suggests I track down pictures and add them to the whiteboard of a cat, sun, and insect for the opening. The issue I have with that is my students at the opening are already overwhelmed, so starting off with CVC words immediately can cause them to shut down. To improve I would use a program like Nearpod or Canva to create interactive and repetitive slides that incorporate spoken recordings, slide & reveal, guess the missing sound, etc that stay specifically in the objective of VC words first, before building up to the next skill level. For a lesson plan generator like this to be considered "sufficiently rigorous" to me, it would need to have generated specific technology platform examples, as well as specific word lists - knowing I gave it my standards, objectives, specific classroom needs and their strengths/weaknesses. To me, (and as discussed during our class) Magic School ai and programs like it are wonderful for inspiration and basic structuring - but a qualified educator is absolutely essential to lesson plan designing and implementing.
Magic School ai Lesson on VC and CVC word building
Part 2:
For part two, I chose to try out the Magic School AI Educational Song Generator. The premise of this tool is that when given a topic, age range and song style, it would generate song lyrics and then an actual song with different voice options. I chose this tool because coincidentally I have been searching for a former teacher's "friends of 10" math addition song I remember she would teach her students to help them remember math facts through the use of a rhyming catchy song. I attempted to recreate it using this Song Generator - and I would give it a solid 7/10 score. Although it missed the mark in some areas, I am impressed how quickly and creatively created an auditory educational song that I personally could not have thought up on my own. I found this tool very useful, especially with students like mine who can be multi-modal or need multiple learning styles in lessons in order to increase working memory and long term storage. For this tool in particular, it would have to be used to to deliver instruction - especially for students who benefit from auditory learning. However, it could also be an alternative form of assessment if older students used it to create a song for a project they were working on.
Part 3:
After reflecting, I would conclude that I can see the benefit of the AI tool and my school special education team could use it to develop lesson ideas for students who are higher or lower than they are generally use to servicing. The challenge with any AI tool is with an instructional lesson that is generated for you rather than created by you, on your own, you are not fully invested or comfortable with how it will all unfold. The AI tool's other features like IEP goal support and parent email generation could be useful for communications that are sent to families for newsletters and general announcements but I don't think it would be a smart idea to use it for more serious topics or the final IEP goal creations, as only the data and team should finalize those based on the unique student. I do feel AI tools can be helpful, however based on the Guidance and Considerations document, and my background in privacy laws - serious thought must go into the use and information provided to tools like these, before they can find a place in the school setting. I have only just started to dip my toes into the world of AI tools - it both excites me and worries me. However, I am looking forward to exploring more options during this course, and beyond.